Cosima's Diaries

Diary Entry of February 10, 1880

Overview

R. slept badly but was cheerful by morning, and the family spent a calm domestic day among the blooming garden and the children’s walk. Beneath his lighter manner, he remained consumed by grim thoughts about Germany, war, the church, and the hold Judaism and Christianity have had on European thought.

Content

Tuesday, February 10:

R. had a very restless night, walked up and down, read Renan; but in the morning he is cheerful, and we spend a nice domestic day together while the children go for a long walk.

We stroll up through the garden, greeted by many things in bloom, and when I say to him at lunch that he seems to me much better, he replies, “Because you were there.”

But his thoughts remain gloomy; though his manner is more cheerful, he exclaimed: “I find it impossible to believe that anything can still become of us Germans. And I should like to remove my children from such a world.” The thought of giving up his son for a war, whether with Russia or France, appalls him. “Outrages have been committed against the people’s feelings; while a poor dying soldier is telling his captain, ‘I die for Germany,’ they are drinking champagne in Versailles, delighted that Bavaria has been brought around; the Devil is leading, and God limping along behind.”

He recalls the fruitless battle at Spichern, the waiting for the Crown Prince at Wörth, for Prince Friedrich Karl at Mars-la-Tour....

Renan’s book provides him with another opportunity to talk about “the most horrible thing in history,” the church, and the victory of Judaism over all else: “I can’t read two lines of Goethe without recognizing the Jewish Jehovah; for him Jesus was a problematical figure, but God was as clear as crystal.” He explains to us how Plato’s Theos paved the way for the Jewish God.