Wagner's Letters

Richard Wagner to Mathilde Wesendonck

Undated · Zurich

Overview

Wagner wonders why his "dear Muse" stays away, reflecting that the Muse, like Love, blesses only freely and cannot be constrained. Ellis conjectured this to be the note intercepted by Minna, which precipitated the crisis of 1858.

Letter

And my dear Muse still stays afar? In silence I awaited her visit; with pleadings I would not disquiet her. For the Muse, like Love, beatifies but freely; woe to the fool, woe to the loveless, who fain would constrain what will not yield itself of its free will. They cannot be constrained; is it not so? Not so? How could Love be Muse withal, did it let itself be forced?

And my dear Muse stays far from me? —

Source: Richard Wagner to Mathilde Wesendonck, trans. William Ashton Ellis (Charles Scribner's Sons, 1905), No. 50