Wagner's Letters

Richard Wagner to Mathilde Wesendonck

May 21, 1859 · Lucerne

Overview

Wagner reports the "comical discovery" that his trouble with Tristan is largely hypochondria: a passage he thought must be recast proved, once fair-copied unchanged, too good to improve. He traces his mistrust of his sketches to having shown them too freely to unsympathetic outsiders, writes on the Schweizerhof's coquettish pink paper, and makes Mathilde a present of his approaching birthday.

Letter

I really must let you into a most comical discovery which I have only just made. It suddenly appears to me as if all the trouble with my work reposed on hypochondria. Everything I have dashed off looks so shockingly bad to me, that I lose all zest, and refuse to go farther. To-day I forced myself to work clean out a passage from the sketch which had so displeased me of late that I believed I must wholly recast it. Nothing better had occurred to me, however, and I was so wretched about it that I thought of giving up, and so on. Finally — in my despair — I fair-copied the passage out to-day, leaving it precisely as in the sketch, save for correction of a few small trifles here and there; I try it over to myself, and — behold you, I find it so good, that I was unable to improve it for that very reason. — Isn't that laughable? — And yet it's ill, for the very happening of this hypochondria is proof enough that something isn't as it should be. I simply cannot prevail on myself to take a thing I have rapidly sketched and render it to myself with warmth and expression. God knows, I'm so entirely the reverse of frugal reserve, that in communication I gladly go beyond all bounds. Yet I also know that I've often had to rue my precipitance in imparting my sketches to outsiders with whom I had no sympathy, and whence I consequently never drew the proper warmth for my own lively grasp of my subject; wherefore I have frequently sworn to do it no more. Now that is avenging itself, and I no longer arrive at making friends with my inspirations at all. However, I'll take a lesson from to-day's experience, and see that I'm not so mistrustful of my drafts another time. That way I shall end by becoming quite flighty, and carrying out the first thing that crops up in my head! —

Enough: for to-day I would rather say no more to you. I'll write you a sensible letter by and by, when I can get hold of other paper than this coquettish pink which the elegant Schweizerhof has purveyed to me. — Even if the weather were quite propitious, I couldn't go up the Rigi to-morrow, as I have had to resort to a medical conference, in result whereof I am Rigi-unfit for some days.

Kindest regards. Keep my birthday for me; I make you a present of it. Consequently — I congratulate!

R. W.

After work!

Source: Richard Wagner to Mathilde Wesendonck, trans. William Ashton Ellis (Charles Scribner's Sons, 1905), No. 77