Cosima's Diaries

Diary Entry of August 18, 1871

Overview

A former sergeant writes of wanting to abandon university for music, prompting Wagner to insist that musicians are born rather than trained. A planned excursion is spoiled by a thunderstorm, so the household turns to games with the children and an evening visit from Countess Ugarte. Beneath the sociability, Cosima is pained by Wagner's growing aversion to the thought of composing.

Content

Friday, August 18:

Our Sergeant Nolte, returned from the war, writes to R. that he has given up his university studies and wants to become a musician. R. emphatically advises him against it, telling him that musicians are born, not made; we intend to educate our Fidi as a surgeon, etc.

We plan an outing to Stanz, but have to give it up on account of a thunderstorm. Games with the children in the salon; in the evening a visit from Countess Ugarte, who tells me that in my outward appearance I look like George Sand’s heroines!

R. thinks about composing music without joy, indeed with a kind of repulsion, which pains me deeply.