Cosima's Diaries

Diary Entry of August 31, 1873

Overview

The children went to church and then to the new house, while R. worked and spoke at lunch about the problem of musical ecstasy replacing reason. He was pleased with his progress in fitting three groups of staves on one page, a technical satisfaction that contrasted with his broader artistic anxieties. Later they finished Coriolanus in the garden with intense emotion, and the diarist praised his reading as essential to understanding the play. The evening brought music with the copyists, including overtures and scenes from his own works, ending with a spirited comparison of the emotional weight of his operas.

Content

Sunday, August 31:

The children to church, then with them to the new house. R. works and says at lunch that he enjoys what he is at present doing, a quartet accompanying a conversation, but when reason ceases and has to be replaced by musical ecstasy, that he finds horrible; now he can fit three groups of staves on one page, and that pleases him.

After lunch we finish Coriolanus in the garden, with indescribable emotion. I tell R. that whoever has not heard him read it does not really know the play, any more than one knows a Beethoven symphony without having heard it conducted by him. We come more and more to the conclusion that it is impossible to imagine these works just by reading them.

In the evening music with our copyists; Die Meistersinger and Faust overtures; then R. sings from Die Walküre. At the end of it we are all of the opinion that Die Walküre is the most emotional, most tragic of all his works, Tristan und Isolde is much more conciliatory, and in Götterdämmerung Hagen at least is a folk figure, which Hunding is not. “amoris,” R. calls out to me in the evening as he bids me good night, after lamenting that constant assaults from the outside world prevent his enjoying his happiness.